Rebuttal to KPMG: Defending Nigeria’s Tax Reforms

Nigeria’s Presidential Fiscal Policy and Tax Reforms Committee firmly addresses KPMG’s critique of the new tax laws, effective January 1, 2026, clarifying misconceptions while highlighting deliberate policy choices for economic growth ​.

Core Disputes with KPMG Report

KPMG labels many provisions as “errors” or “gaps,” yet these largely stem from the firm’s misinterpretations, overlooked reform contexts, or preferences diverging from enacted policies. The committee values KPMG’s input on implementation risks but rejects framing disagreements as flaws, urging direct engagement like other firms pursued ​. Valid clerical issues exist and are under internal review, separate from substantive policy.

Key Policy Clarifications

• Share Gains Taxation: Rates range from 0% to 30% (reducing to 25%), with 99% of investors exempt outright or via reinvestment; stock market highs refute sell-off fears ​.
• Commencement and Transition: A fixed accounting start ignores multi-period complexities like audits and penalties; the chosen approach handles ongoing transactions effectively.
• Indirect Share Transfers: Aligns with BEPS global standards to close multinational loopholes, preserving competitiveness without economic harm.
• VAT on Insurance: Premiums fall outside “taxable supplies” by definition, rendering explicit exemptions redundant.

Addressing Specific Misunderstandings

KPMG questions “community” in ‘person’ definitions, but statutory rules apply definitions universally unless context dictates otherwise, streamlining modern drafting ​. The Joint Revenue Board’s revenue-agency focus mirrors successful prior models for subnational coordination. Dividend treatments distinguish foreign versus Nigerian sources logically, as foreign dividends lack local withholding credits ​.

Non-residents face registration despite final taxes on some income, mirroring resident filing duties for oversight beyond revenue alone.

Rejecting Undermining Proposals

Exempting foreign insurers would disadvantage local firms, violating fair competition goals. Disallowing parallel-market forex deductions bolsters Naira stability by curbing round-tripping. VAT-linked deductibility enforces ecosystem compliance, with self-charging options available ​. The 25% top personal rate (effective ~22% post-pension) remains competitive versus peers like Ghana (35%) or U.S. (37%), balancing progressivity and growth.

ADVERTISEMENT

Factual Corrections

The Police Trust Fund expired June 2025, nullifying repeal needs. Small company exemptions predate reforms via 2021 Finance Act, not a new inconsistency ​.

Overlooked Reform Wins

KPMG underplays achievements: corporate tax cut to 25%, VAT exemptions/credits expansion, small business relief under ₦100m turnover, minimum tax abolition, and sector incentives—all fostering sustainability ​​.

Path Forward

Post-consultation and public hearings, focus shifts to guidance, regulations, and partnerships for smooth rollout. Stakeholders should embrace collaborative implementation over critique.